Sunday, May 1, 2011

Valuevision Media: Our Top Small Cap Media Pick.

ValueVision Media (VVTV) is set to report earnings on May 11, 2011. Research firm Piper Jaffray is calling for revenues of $146.7 million, Adjusted EBITDA of ($0.962), and GAAP EPS of ($0.73). We think those estimates are easily beatable and the shares are likely to rally post the earnings.

Friday’s favorable decision from Liberty Interactive regarding the bondholder lawsuit should be viewed as a catalyst for the TV Shopping industry, and VVTV in particular, because it could mean that QVC and HSN would be cleared to merge in the future. Comcast in our view, would not sit idle and let QVC and HSN become overbearing as a combined competitor, and could invest in VVTV to make it more competitive. We think that would ultimately lead to a full acquisition of VVTV by Comcast.

In addition, Comcast’s declaration last week that it would cross promote its assets is also favorable for VVTV.

We have pushed the acquisition thesis on VVTV before, seen here, and thinks it makes sense for Comcast, but also for a company like Amazon.com, who could stand to both increase sales and margins if it had a TV distribution outlet. The margins on a multichannel shopping purchase is higher than that of a pure online shopping purchase or that of a pure TV shopping purchase. A TV channel would allow Amazon.com in our view to ultimately get to the double digit operating margin goal.

As a standalone business we are calculating a fair value for VVTV shares of around $8 based on a 8.5x multiple to fiscal 2013 consensus EBITDA of $50 million.

And as for the Wall Street Journal article about the insider share sales, which we view as fair to bring up, we note that the article did not mention that the CEO had purchased 1 million shares in the open market in 2009. From a pure corporate governance perspective we do not like one-time insider shares sales because of the signaling hypothesis. But be that it may, the business is fundamentally strong and has great momentum, so we are willing to overlook that at this time, and look to the upside potential from owning the shares.


9 comments:

  1. The $50 Million - 2013 EBITDA number does not "as you suggest"... account for ... any potential involvement of COMCAST in (VVTV)

    As such .. all growth forecasts ... could be well under-estimated

    As well as your $8.00 Price Target

    Comcast .... should want to own and consolidate (VVTV's) ----> "Shop-NBC" ..&.. "Shop-NBC.com" - Media Assets...

    This type of transaction would allow COMCAST to --> merge the "ShopNBC & ShopNBC.com" assets .... into the much larger - National Broadcasting Company - "NBC"

    It makes little financial or common sense..... for Comcast to allow (VVTV) to continue to control and operate the - "Shop-NBC" - brand name and assets...
    as an independant - 3rd party.

    By consolidating - (VVTV's) - "Shop-NBC" - brands under one roof... with ... The National Broadcasting Company - "NBC"

    Comcast can then substantially.... reduce tens of millions in operating costs and overhead..... and then aggressively grow the ShopNBC & ShopNBC.com businesses ...

    This would be relatively easy for Comcast to do ..... especially with "NBC's" far greater financial capabilities and massive scale within the media industry

    VVTV is now selling for just ----> 0.38 x (times) --> 2012 Sales Estimates / Net Enterprise Value

    I believe that (VVTV) management could probably sell the company Today for... at least 1x times .... 2012 - Sales estimates of $640 Million Dollars ....

    This would equate to a (VVTV) stock price of approximately ====> $14.00 a Share

    VVTV is actually worth ...$13.92 a Share ------> Valued at just ---> 1x times - 2012 (VVTV) Sales Estimates of ===> $640 Million Dollars

    For those that believe (VVTV) Management's ----> 2015 Revenue Estimates of more than -----> $1 BILLION in Annualized Sales

    Then VVTV's stock price ..... could be worth something north of ====>

    $25.00+ a Share / over time

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with your analysis about the synergy with NBC. I think we are using different share counts. I am using the fully diluted share count that assumes VVTV is profitable.

    ReplyDelete
  3. COMCAST now owns ==> 6,466,938 shares of (VVTV)

    As a consequence... COMCAST is now ==> (VVTV's) Largest Shareholder

    COMCAST's - (VVTV) Ownership Filing -- Dated: February 7, 2011
    LINK:
    http://xml.10kwizard.com/filing_raw.php?repo=tenk&ipage=7383834

    ================================================
    COMCAST has already made .."BILLIONS".... in the Home Shopping Business....

    COMCAST has previously sold their ...
    57% percent equity ownership stake in the "QVC" - Home Shopping Network ....to John Malone's - Liberty Media Corporation for ====> $7.9 BILLION DOLLARS
    LINK:
    http://www.comcast.com/About/PressReleas...


    Clearly this is .."NOT".. COMCAST's first rodeo...... in the "Home Shopping" business

    Now that COMCAST has become (VVTV's) single largest shareholder.... with a roughly 20% ownership interest in VVTV

    It is now in COMCAST's... "Best Financial Interest"... to see (VVTV's) core business assets (ShopNBC ..&.. ShopNBC.com) ---> become wildly successful.

    If COMCAST can replicate the "MONSTER" success they have already had in the "home shopping" business with .."QVC".... here again at (VVTV)

    Then it's in COMCAST's "Best Financial Interest" ---->

    To scale up (VVTV's) business & cuts costs ..... and then sell it for ---->

    BILLIONS

    If Wall Street starts to believe that COMCAST is angling for yet ..... another.... "Huge Score" in the "home shopping" segement

    Then look for COMCAST to take a more "Significant" and "Active" role at (VVTV).... such as filling the 2 Board seats that GE is about to abdicate w/ COMCAST executives

    Should this happen ---->

    Then there is literally ......no limit.... to how high (VVTV's) stock price can go.......

    ================================================
    MORE LIKELY --> COMCAST will --> "BUY-OUT"... (VVTV) Shareholders
    ================================================

    The other ... Likely Alternative....

    COMCAST will make an .... out-right -->
    "Take-Over Bid" ---> for all of (VVTV's) shares they don't already own

    If COMCAST decides to "BUY-BACK" ---> NBC's Home Shopping Business --> This would make some very solid business sense

    Especially if COMCAST truly believes that they sitting on ---> Their next "QVC" type investment

    This type of transaction would make a ton of sense...

    Considering that COMCAST just paid $13.8 Billion Dollars for ---> NBC / Universal

    LINK: Comcast Wins Approval... to BUY... NBC /Universal from General Electric (GE) --> for $13.8 Billion

    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-01-18/comcast-nbc-universal-deal-said-to-be-near-u-s-fcc-approval.html

    ReplyDelete

Custom Search